English
English한국어日本語简体中文繁體中文EspañolPortuguêsFrançaisItalianoDeutschРусскийTürkçeالعربيةBahasa IndonesiaTiếng ViệtไทยМонголမြန်မာBahasa Melayuहिन्दीҚазақшаOʻzbekchaPolskiУкраїнськаNederlands
Get a quote

Blog

What do vegan and cruelty-free claims require before they go on a label?

Buyers ask us for both claims on almost every first call. The honest answer is that neither is ours to give, and here is what it takes to earn them.

Illustrative image of a skincare bottle among fresh leaves and botanicalsIllustrative image

What does each claim actually mean?

ClaimWhat it saysWhat has to be true
VeganNo ingredient of animal originEvery raw material, including processing aids, carriers and colourants, is traced to a non-animal source; beeswax, lanolin, collagen, carmine, honey and some glycerin or squalane grades are the usual exclusions
Cruelty-free, not tested on animalsNo animal testing of the finished product or its ingredientsThe manufacturer, the raw material suppliers and the brand have policies and records covering testing for the product's markets; some certifiers also set a cut-off date after which no ingredient may have been animal-tested

The two are separate. A product can be vegan and have ingredients that were animal-tested; a product can be free of animal testing and contain beeswax. Buyers often ask for both in one word, so we ask which one they mean.

Why do these claims need third-party substantiation?

Neither claim has a harmonised legal definition in the EU, the US or Korea. What exists is a general rule that claims on cosmetics must be true and provable. For an ingredient-origin claim or a testing claim that reaches back through dozens of suppliers, the only practical proof is an audit by a body that does this for a living: it reviews the formula, requests supplier declarations for each raw material, and issues a certificate that names the product and the brand.

Read moreShow less

Three things follow for a brand buying from Korea:

  1. The certificate belongs to a product and a brand, not to a factory. Even if a partner line has certified products for another client, your product is certified only when it is audited.
  2. The manufacturer's declaration is an input, not the proof. We can collect raw material declarations from the partner line and its suppliers; the certifier decides whether they are enough.
  3. Certification is a separate cost and a separate timeline. It is quoted at cost, like registration, and it runs in parallel with the CPSR or the MoCRA listing rather than inside them.

What does the EU require of any claim?

Commission Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 lays down common criteria that every claim on a cosmetic product in the EU must meet. They apply equally to "vegan", "for sensitive skin" and "48-hour hydration".

Read moreShow less
CriterionIn practice
Legal complianceA claim cannot say the product is allowed to do something the law requires anyway
TruthfulnessIf you say an ingredient is in, it is in; if you say it is out, it is out
Evidential supportAdequate and verifiable evidence sits in the Product Information File
HonestyNo exaggeration of what the product or the ingredient does
FairnessNo denigration of competitors or of legally used ingredients
Informed decision-makingThe claim is understandable to the average consumer

For animal testing there is one more layer. Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 bans animal testing of cosmetic products and ingredients for cosmetic purposes in the EU and bans the marketing of products tested elsewhere to meet the regulation. The Commission's technical guidance on claims treats "not tested on animals" as a claim that must not suggest a benefit over products that comply with the same ban. A UK or German retailer will read your label with that guidance in hand.

What is BIGPIE C&T's position?

We do not claim that our products, including the PURYNN range and the 4 ready formulas, are vegan or cruelty-free, because we have not had them certified and we do not own the lines or the raw material supply chain. What we do when a buyer needs one of the claims:

Read moreShow less
  • Ask which claim, for which market and which retailer, because the standard the retailer accepts decides the certifier.
  • Check the partner line for that project: its raw material sources, its testing policy and whether it has been audited before.
  • Review the formula for the usual animal-derived exclusions and propose substitutes where a formula change is possible (from 1,000 units for skincare, adjusted or newly developed).
  • Collect the supplier declarations the certifier asks for and quote the certification cost separately.

If the claim cannot be substantiated for your product, we say so before the label is printed.

"When a buyer asks for a vegan and cruelty-free label on a 300-unit order, I explain that the ready formulas are not certified and that certification is per product. Most buyers then launch without the claim and add it on the second order, once there is a budget for the audit." — Minjae Lee, Head of Overseas Sales

What should you do before printing the claim?

  1. Decide the claim and the market. "Vegan" for an EU drugstore and "cruelty-free" for a US online shop are two different audits.
  2. Ask your manufacturer for the full INCI list with the origin of each ingredient marked.
  3. Ask whether the line and its suppliers can issue the declarations the certifier requires.
  4. Budget the certification and its renewal, separately from the unit price.
  5. Keep the evidence in the PIF so the EU Responsible Person can show it on request.
  6. Until the certificate exists, leave the claim off the label and the listing.

Are the ready private label formulas vegan?

We do not claim that they are. The formulas have not been audited for ingredient origin. If you need the claim, we review the INCI list with the partner line and quote a certification route.

Does "made in Korea" mean cruelty-free?

No. The country of manufacture does not substantiate a testing claim. The claim depends on the policies and records of the manufacturer, its suppliers and the brand, verified by a certifier.

Can you add a vegan logo to my label?

Only with the certificate from the body that owns the logo, in your brand's name. We print what you are licensed to print.

How is a claim checked in the EU?

By the Responsible Person's evidence in the Product Information File, against the six common criteria of Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, and by national market surveillance authorities.

Does certification change the unit price?

No. It is quoted at cost as a separate line, like registration. A formula change to remove an animal-derived ingredient may change the unit price.

Sources

  1. Commission Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 laying down common criteria for the justification of claims used in relation to cosmetic products, EUR-Lex
  2. Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products, Article 18 animal testing, EUR-Lex
  3. Cosmetics claims, European Commission

Tell us the claim, the market and the retailer, and we will check the partner line before you spend on an audit. Ask about claims

Tell us what you want to make.

Send the product, market and quantity. You get a written quote and a formula route within 24 hours.

WhatsApp
Get a quoteWhatsApp