Blog
Why does sunscreen for the US need 10,000 units when other markets need 5,000?
In Korea and the EU a sunscreen is a cosmetic with extra rules. In the US it is a drug. The minimum follows the law, not the formula.
Illustrative imageWhat makes a sunscreen a drug in the US?
Any product sold in the US with an SPF claim or that is intended to prevent sunburn is an OTC drug under the FDA's sunscreen monograph. The monograph lists which active ingredients (the UV filters) may be used, at which concentrations, how the product must be tested and what the label must say. A sunscreen also has to be made on a line that follows the FDA's drug manufacturing rules, and the product is listed with the FDA as a drug rather than as a cosmetic under MoCRA.
Read moreShow less
In Korea, by contrast, sunscreen is a functional cosmetic: the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS) reviews the SPF and PA data before the product is sold in Korea, but the product stays a cosmetic. The EU treats it as a cosmetic under Regulation 1223/2009 with an approved UV filter list in Annex VI. So the same formula can be a cosmetic in Seoul and Berlin and a drug in Los Angeles.
What does a US sunscreen run need that other markets do not?
| Requirement | Korea and EU | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Legal status | Cosmetic (functional cosmetic in Korea) | OTC drug |
| UV filters | Korean and EU approved lists, which include newer organic filters | FDA monograph list only; several newer organic filters common in Korean sunscreens are not on it |
| Efficacy tests | SPF and PA (Korea) or SPF and UVA (EU) on human subjects | SPF test, broad-spectrum test and, if claimed, water-resistance test on the final formula, by the FDA's methods |
| Label | Cosmetic label with SPF and PA or UVA markings | Drug Facts panel: active ingredients, uses, warnings, directions, plus cosmetic-style ingredient listing |
| Registration | MFDS functional cosmetic review (Korea); CPNP notification (EU) | Drug establishment registration and drug listing for the product |
| Line | Cosmetic manufacturing | Line operating under the FDA's drug manufacturing rules |
Read moreShow less
Each row on the right is a fixed cost. The SPF study is the same price for 5,000 units or 50,000. The Drug Facts label is a separate artwork. The partner lines in our network that run US sunscreen set 10,000 as the smallest batch where those costs make sense, and the number cannot be reduced or reached by combining SKUs.
Hybrid or mineral: which is easier for the US?
Korean sunscreens are known for light hybrid textures that mix organic (chemical) and inorganic (mineral) filters. The catch is the filter list.
Read moreShow less
- Mineral filters. Zinc oxide and titanium dioxide are on the FDA list and on the Korean and EU lists. A mineral sunscreen developed for Korea can usually go to the US with a label change and the US tests. The texture is heavier and whiter, which is the trade-off.
- Hybrid and organic filters. Several of the organic filters that make Korean sunscreens feel light are approved in Korea and the EU but not in the US. A hybrid formula for the US is usually reformulated with US-permitted organic filters, which changes the texture, and then tested again.
- One formula for all markets. Possible with a mineral base or with organic filters that appear on all three lists, but the texture is less "Korean" than buyers expect. We say this at the sample stage, not after the order.
The practical answer for most brands is two SKUs: a Korean-style hybrid for Asia, the Gulf and the EU at 5,000 units, and a US-compliant version at 10,000 units if and when the US channel justifies it.
"Sun care is 9% of our sample requests and one of the categories where we most often say no to the first brief. When a buyer wants 3,000 units of a Korean hybrid sunscreen for Amazon US, we explain the OTC rules and the 10,000 minimum, and most of them start with a serum or a cream instead." — Minjae Lee, Head of Overseas Sales
What does the project look like?
- Brief. Target SPF, texture (hybrid or mineral), market list and quantity per market. We reply within 24 hours and tell you whether the US version needs a separate formula.
- Sample. About 2 weeks for a development sample, USD 150 credited against production. For the US version the filters are chosen from the FDA list from the start.
- Testing. SPF and broad-spectrum testing on the final formula at a test laboratory, quoted at cost. Stability and compatibility tests run on the chosen container.
- Label and listing data. We supply the formula, filter concentrations and the ingredient declaration for the Drug Facts panel; your US responsible party handles the drug listing and label approval.
- Production. 50% deposit, 2 to 3 months including containers, golden sample approval, balance before shipment on EXW or FOB terms.
Registration and testing costs are quoted separately from the unit price, as for any market; see the fees page.
Can I order 5,000 units of sunscreen for the US if I accept a higher unit price?
No. The 10,000 minimum covers the fixed costs of an OTC drug batch: filters, testing, Drug Facts label and listing. It is the same on every route and cannot be split across SKUs.
Is a Korean SPF 50+ PA++++ result accepted by the FDA?
No. The FDA requires SPF, broad-spectrum and water-resistance testing by its own methods on the final formula. The Korean MFDS result supports the Korean claim and is useful evidence, but the US tests are run separately.
Can I sell the same sunscreen in the EU and the US?
Only if every filter is on both lists, which usually means a mineral or a conservative organic formula. Most Korean hybrid sunscreens need a US-specific version.
Do you handle the FDA drug listing?
No. We supply the data; your US company or distributor is the listed responsible party. We can introduce a regulatory service and the cost is quoted at cost.
What is the minimum for sunscreen in other markets?
5,000 units per SKU on the OEM/ODM route for Asia, the EU, the Gulf and other non-US markets. Sunscreen is not available on the 300-unit private label route.
Sources
Tell us your target SPF, texture and the markets you will sell in, and we will quote the Korean version at 5,000 and the US version at 10,000 within 24 hours. Request a sunscreen quote
Tell us what you want to make.
Send the product, market and quantity. You get a written quote and a formula route within 24 hours.